Cliff has started a good dialogue in his post below. I thought I’d add my 10 cents, for what it’s worth.
A program rises and falls on the experience and ability of its players, and experience and ability are obtained by participating in intensive practices and meaningful games. Players who immerse themselves in that environment year-round tend to refine their skills and knowledge of the game faster than the players who don’t.
The chart below illustrates the correlation between varsity-player club soccer participation and winning percentages throughout my 11 eleven years as Parkview’s head coach. While the numbers are partially from my memory, the numbers are very close, and the general trend clearly shows the impact of year-round soccer participation on the team’s success each season. Everyone might consider too how the Parkview program has ebbed and flowed over the years (see chart at the very bottom of this post).

Number of Club Players to Winning Percentage, 2000-2010. The numbers are bit from memory but still show the relationship between club participation and winning percentages. The numbers focus on the varsity rosters. A variable for which the chart does not account is schedule strength, which generally has become much more difficult now that 10 years ago.
Imagine a violinist who doesn’t perform or take lessons nine months out of the year and yet hopes to be selected to the Springfield youth symphony. Others will arrive at the audition better prepared to execute to their full potential under pressure, and they likely will be the ones chosen. That’s not a surprise. The point is that kids who devote themselves year-round to their craft are the ones who achieve the most. » Read more: Coach’s Commentary: Play More Soccer




